Avalon vs. Bennington: Which Pontoon Should You Buy? – Head-to-Head Comparison for Smart Buyers
Choosing between Avalon and Bennington is like picking between two legendary quarterbacks—both are top-tier performers, but each brings something unique to the game. Let’s cut through the marketing hype and figure out which pontoon deserves a spot in your marina slip.
The Premium Pontoon Showdown: What’s Really at Stake
Avalon and Bennington aren’t your average pontoon boats. These are the brands serious boaters consider when they want quality, performance, and longevity. Both companies have earned their reputations through decades of innovation, but they take different approaches to pontoon design and construction.
The question isn’t whether these boats are good—they’re both excellent. The real question is: which one matches your boating style, budget, and priorities? I’ve spent time on both brands, talked to owners, and dug into the specs. Here’s what you need to know before writing that check.
Construction Quality: Where These Boats Are Built to Last
Let’s start with what keeps you floating: construction. Bennington pioneered the ESP (Elliptical Sport Package) tube design back in the 1990s, featuring elliptical-shaped pontoons that slice through water more efficiently than traditional round tubes. This design improves handling, increases speed potential, and provides better rough-water performance.
Avalon counters with their V-Toon Technology and Triple-Toon Performance Package. The V-shaped center toon creates a keel effect, dramatically improving handling and stability. In choppy conditions, the difference is noticeable—the boat tracks straighter and pitches less.
Both brands use marine-grade aluminum throughout their construction, but the gauges vary by model. Bennington’s premium QP (Quad Pontoon) models feature .100-gauge tubes—seriously beefy construction that laughs at rough water. Avalon’s GS Elite series uses .080 to .090-gauge aluminum depending on configuration.
“The gauge thickness debate gets overblown in pontoon forums. Both brands exceed industry standards, and most recreational boaters will never stress their tubes enough to notice the difference. Focus on how the boat performs for your specific use.”
Design Philosophy: Form Meets Function
Avalon has earned a reputation for luxury and customization. Walk through an Avalon dealership and you’ll find an almost overwhelming array of upholstery options, floor patterns, and layout configurations. Their Catalina models showcase this approach—think premium furniture-grade vinyl, LED accent lighting, and thoughtful storage solutions everywhere.
Bennington takes a more performance-focused approach without sacrificing comfort. Their SX and R Series models prioritize speed and handling while still delivering plush seating and quality amenities. The layouts tend toward open, functional designs that maximize usable deck space.
Here’s where personal preference matters: Do you want a floating living room with endless customization (Avalon), or a sporty performer that looks great and handles like a dream (Bennington)?
Performance Comparison: How They Handle on the Water
Speed and Handling Characteristics
Bennington’s elliptical tubes and aggressive hull designs give them an edge in outright speed. A Bennington 25 SSRX with a 300HP Yamaha can push 40+ MPH with the right setup. The boats plane off quickly and maintain impressive stability at higher speeds.
Avalon’s V-Toon equipped models deliver excellent performance too, typically hitting the mid-30s MPH range with comparable power. Where they really shine is in cornering stability. That center V-toon acts like a keel, keeping the boat planted during tight turns. You can bank into curves more aggressively without the outer tube lifting.
I once watched an Avalon LSZ Elite cruise series through a slalom course that would make most pontoons wallow—it carved those turns like a ski boat.
Rough Water Capability
Both brands handle chop better than entry-level pontoons, but they approach it differently. Bennington’s ESP tubes cut through waves rather than riding over them, creating a smoother ride in moderate chop. The design reduces pounding and keeps passengers comfortable.
Avalon’s triple-toon configurations with lifting strakes provide incredible stability in rough conditions. The extra buoyancy and surface area mean less porpoising and pitching. For big water boating—think Great Lakes or coastal bays—this matters.
Features and Amenities: What You Get for Your Money
Standard Equipment and Upgrades
Bennington generally includes more performance features as standard equipment. Their SternGate swim platform, under-deck LED lighting, and premium sound systems often come standard on mid-range models. You’re paying for a complete package rather than endless add-ons.
Avalon takes the à la carte approach. Base models are well-equipped but affordable, and you build from there. Want upgraded speakers? Captain’s chair with flip-up bolster? Underwater lighting? It’s all available—just expect to pay for each addition.
This philosophical difference affects total cost. A comparably equipped Avalon might run $5,000-$8,000 less than a Bennington with similar features, but that gap narrows when you add Avalon’s premium options.
Furniture and Comfort Features
Both brands use high-density marine vinyl that resists fading and mildew. Bennington’s Bimini seating provides impressive lumbar support and uses thicker cushion foam (approximately 4 inches vs. the industry standard 3 inches). Their chaise lounges and L-shaped configurations maximize passenger capacity.
Avalon’s Deluxe furniture packages feature unique patterns and two-tone color schemes you won’t find elsewhere. The stitching quality is exceptional, and their captain’s chairs offer excellent ergonomics for all-day comfort. Storage compartments integrate seamlessly into seat bases.
Comparison: Avalon vs. Bennington at a Glance
| Feature | Avalon | Bennington | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tube Design | Round/V-Toon hybrid, lifting strakes | Elliptical ESP, traditional rounds | Tie (different strengths) |
| Top Speed Potential | 35-38 MPH (comparable power) | 38-42 MPH (comparable power) | Bennington |
| Rough Water Handling | Excellent (triple-toon stability) | Excellent (ESP wave-cutting) | Tie |
| Customization Options | Extensive (100+ configurations) | Good (50+ configurations) | Avalon |
| Standard Equipment Value | Good (build your own) | Excellent (package approach) | Bennington |
| Build Quality | Excellent (.080-.090 gauge) | Excellent (.090-.100 gauge) | Tie |
| Price Range (23ft model) | $55,000-$75,000 | $62,000-$82,000 | Avalon (value) |
| Resale Value | Very Good (85-90% at 3 years) | Excellent (90-95% at 3 years) | Bennington |
Price and Value: Getting the Most Boat for Your Budget
Initial Purchase Price
Avalon typically comes in $5,000-$10,000 less expensive than Bennington for similarly sized boats with basic equipment. A 23-foot Avalon Catalina Platinum with a 150HP Yamaha might run $62,000, while a comparable 23-foot Bennington SX Series could hit $70,000.
But here’s the catch: once you start adding options to match the Bennington’s standard features, that gap closes. Bennington’s package approach often delivers better value if you want most of the available upgrades anyway.
Long-Term Ownership Costs
Both brands require similar maintenance—regular cleaning, upholstery care, and engine service. Where Bennington pulls ahead is resale value. The brand commands premium prices in the used market, typically retaining 90-95% of original value after three years (assuming good condition and average hours).
Avalon holds value well too—around 85-90% over the same period—but Bennington’s stronger brand recognition translates to quicker sales and higher asking prices. If you upgrade boats every 5-7 years, that 5% difference adds up to thousands of dollars.
Warranty Coverage
Bennington offers a 10-year bow-to-stern warranty on structural components, including tubes, deck, and railings. Their gelcoat and upholstery carry shorter coverage (typically 3-5 years), but the structural warranty is industry-leading.
Avalon provides a 7-year limited structural warranty with similar coverage areas. Both companies warranty engines separately through the outboard manufacturer (Yamaha, Mercury, etc.). Neither warranty covers damage from neglect, accidents, or saltwater corrosion without proper maintenance.
Real Owner Experiences: What People Actually Say
I reached out to owners’ groups and marina communities to get unfiltered feedback. Here’s what consistently came up:
Avalon owners love:
- The ability to create a truly custom boat that reflects their style
- Thoughtful storage solutions and practical layouts
- Responsive customer service from dealers
- Value proposition—getting premium features without the premium price
Avalon owners wish:
- The brand had more name recognition (resale concern)
- Base models included more standard equipment
- Dealer networks were more widespread in some regions
Bennington owners love:
- The brand reputation and resale value
- Out-of-the-box performance without extensive upgrades
- Build quality and attention to detail
- How the boats handle in various water conditions
Bennington owners wish:
- The initial purchase price was more competitive
- More customization options were available
- Certain premium features weren’t bundled (forcing you to pay for things you don’t want)
Which Pontoon Should You Choose?
Buy an Avalon If You:
- Want maximum customization and personal style expression
- Prefer building your boat à la carte to control costs
- Value getting premium features at a more accessible price point
- Plan to keep your boat long-term (7+ years)
- Prioritize luxury and comfort over outright performance
- Appreciate thoughtful storage and organization features
Buy a Bennington If You:
- Want the highest resale value and brand recognition
- Prefer complete, pre-configured packages over endless options
- Need maximum performance for watersports or big-water cruising
- Value having the “known quantity” that other boaters recognize
- Plan to upgrade boats every 5-7 years
- Want the thickest gauge tubes and most aggressive hull designs
The Real Answer: Test Drive Both
Here’s what I tell everyone asking this question: get on the water with both brands. Specs and reviews only tell part of the story. You need to feel how each boat handles, sit in the captain’s chair, and envision your family on that deck.
Many dealers will arrange demo rides or can connect you with owners willing to show off their boats. Take advantage of boat shows where you can compare multiple models side-by-side. The “right” pontoon is the one that matches your specific boating style and budget—not the one with the most impressive spec sheet.
Frequently Asked Questions: Avalon vs. Bennington
Which brand is better for saltwater use? Both handle saltwater well if properly maintained. Bennington’s thicker gauge tubes (.100) provide extra corrosion resistance, but regular freshwater rinsing and anti-corrosion treatments matter more than gauge thickness. Neither brand specifically warranties against saltwater damage without proper maintenance protocols.
Do Avalon boats hold up as well as Bennington over time? Yes—both brands use quality materials and construction methods. Long-term durability depends more on maintenance than brand choice. Properly cared for, either boat should deliver 20-30 years of service.
Which pontoon is better for fishing? Avalon offers more fishing-specific packages with dedicated rod holders, livewells, and tackle storage. Bennington’s open deck layouts provide more casting space. Your fishing style determines the winner—structure fishing favors Avalon’s features, while open-water trolling benefits from Bennington’s speed and deck space.
Can I get a triple-toon configuration from both brands? Yes. Avalon offers triple-toon setups across most model lines, while Bennington provides triple and even quad-toon options on premium models. Both deliver excellent performance with three tubes, though Bennington’s quad setup is unmatched for rough water capability.
Which brand has better dealer support? This varies by region. Bennington has slightly broader dealer coverage nationally, but Avalon dealers often provide more personalized service. Research dealers in your area—a great local dealer beats a distant “better” brand every time.
Are the furniture and upholstery comparable in quality? Both use premium marine vinyl and high-density foam. Bennington’s cushions run slightly thicker (4″ vs 3.5″), but Avalon’s stitching and pattern options are more extensive. Quality is essentially equal—preference comes down to style and comfort feel.
How much should I budget beyond the base boat price? Plan for 15-25% above the base price for essential additions like upgraded power, electronics, covers, and trailer upgrades. Avalon’s à la carte approach gives more control here, while Bennington’s packages simplify budgeting but may include features you don’t need.
Making Your Final Decision
The Avalon vs. Bennington debate doesn’t have a universal winner because these boats serve slightly different audiences. Bennington is the performance-focused, brand-name choice with outstanding resale value. Avalon is the value-minded luxury option with unmatched customization.
Both companies build exceptional pontoons that will deliver years of enjoyment on the water. Your choice should reflect your priorities: Do you value performance and resale above all else? Bennington wins. Do you want the best features-per-dollar and a boat that reflects your personal style? Avalon takes it.
The good news? You can’t go wrong with either choice. Both brands have earned their reputations through quality, innovation, and customer satisfaction. Now get out there, test drive both, and pick the one that makes you smile when you walk up to the dock.
Which pontoon brand gets your vote? Team Avalon or Team Bennington? Drop a comment below and tell us what tipped the scales for you!
References:
