Fishing Pontoon Boat: Choosing the Perfect Model for Your Angling Adventures

You’re standing in a boat dealership surrounded by gleaming pontoons, each one promising to be “the ultimate fishing machine,” and suddenly you realize—how do you actually pick the right one when they all look pretty much the same from the outside?

Understanding What Makes a Fishing Pontoon Different

Not all pontoons are created equal, and fishing-specific models pack features that standard party pontoons just don’t have. I’ve watched too many anglers buy a beautiful cruiser pontoon, then spend thousands trying to retrofit it with fishing gear they should’ve had from the factory. Let’s make sure you don’t make that expensive mistake.

A true fishing pontoon includes purpose-built features like livewells with aeration systems, reinforced decking that can handle fish slime and hook drops, integrated rod storage compartments, and mounting points specifically designed for downriggers or rod holders. Brands like Lowe, Bennington, Manitou, and Avalon offer dedicated fishing packages that include these essentials right out of the gate.

The difference goes beyond just add-ons, though. Fishing pontoons typically use sturdier construction—think 25-inch diameter pontoon tubes instead of 23-inch, thicker gauge aluminum, and deck layouts optimized for casting rather than entertaining. You’re paying for functionality that’ll make your fishing life easier, not just chrome and cupholders.

Key Features Every Fishing Pontoon Should Have

Livewell Systems: Keeping Your Catch Fresh

A quality livewell isn’t negotiable if you practice catch-and-release or want to bring fish home in prime condition. Look for livewells with at least 20-gallon capacity—the Bennington QX series offers a 30-gallon recirculating livewell that keeps bass and walleye healthy for hours.

The best systems include both fill and drain pumps, not just overflow drains. Timer-controlled aeration is another feature worth seeking out. The Lowe Ultra 202 Fish & Cruise has a livewell system with a blue interior (easier to see fish condition) and rounded corners that prevent fish from getting stuck in sharp angles.

Here’s something dealers won’t always mention: check where the livewell drains. If it drains through the deck into the bilge area, you’re asking for smell problems. Livewells that drain directly overboard are much cleaner and easier to maintain.

Deck Layout and Fishing Space

Walk onto a fishing pontoon and immediately notice the open floor plan. You shouldn’t be dodging furniture to get to your rod. The Sun Tracker Fishin’ Barge series uses a bow fishing deck design—an open, elevated platform up front where you can cast freely without rails or seats blocking your swing.

Casting decks make a huge difference. Raised platforms at the bow or stern give you better sight lines into the water and more room for backcasts. The Manitou Fishin’ Director models feature a removable casting platform that you can install when fishing or take out when you want more passenger seating.

Floor space matters too. Measure the continuous open deck area—you want at least 6-8 feet of unobstructed space where multiple anglers can fish comfortably. Some models sacrifice this for extra furniture, which looks nice in photos but frustrates you on the water.

Rod Storage Solutions

Ever had a $300 rod setup roll off the deck into the lake? Factory-installed rod lockers prevent this nightmare. Look for horizontal storage tubes built into the gunwales—they protect rods during transport and keep them secure while running between spots.

Vertical rod holders mounted on rails serve a different purpose. You’ll want 6-10 of these around the boat’s perimeter for trolling or storing rods while fishing. The Avalon Catalina Entertainer Fish includes 8 flush-mount rod holders as standard equipment, which would cost you $200+ to add aftermarket.

“The worst time to realize you don’t have enough rod holders is when you’re on a hot walleye bite and you’ve got five lines you want in the water simultaneously.”

Don’t overlook under-seat storage. Tackle boxes, nets, and rain gear need homes where they won’t slide around. The Crest Caribbean LX fishing model includes four large under-seat storage compartments with gas struts that hold lids open—small details that matter when you’re wrestling a net and need gear fast.

Size Matters: Finding Your Ideal Length

Compact Models (16-19 Feet)

These smaller fishing pontoons fit tighter budgets and smaller bodies of water. The Lowe SF212 Sport Fish (18 feet) is popular among anglers fishing farm ponds and small lakes. You’ll get excellent maneuverability, easier trailering, and lower fuel costs.

The downside? Less stability in rough water and cramped quarters with more than three anglers. Storage space becomes limited quickly. These work beautifully for solo anglers or fishing buddies who don’t need luxury amenities.

Expect to pay $18,000-$28,000 for a new 16-19 foot fishing pontoon with a 40-60 hp outboard. Used models from 2018-2020 run $12,000-$20,000 depending on condition and features.

Mid-Size Sweet Spot (20-23 Feet)

This range hits the perfect balance for most anglers. A 22-foot fishing pontoon like the Bennington 22 SSX gives you room for 4-6 people comfortably, enough storage for serious gear, and sufficient deck space for multiple fishing techniques.

The wider beam (typically 8.5 feet) provides excellent stability. You can stand and cast without feeling tippy, kids can move around safely, and waves don’t toss you around like a cork. Fuel capacity usually hits 30-35 gallons, giving you decent range for bigger lakes.

Power requirements jump here—you’ll want 90-115 hp for proper performance. Figure $35,000-$55,000 new, or $25,000-$40,000 for used models (2018-2021) in good shape with upgrades.

Serious Fishing Rigs (24-27 Feet)

When you need maximum fishing capability, these larger platforms deliver. The Sun Tracker Party Barge 24 XP3 or the Manitou 25 Legacy SHP offer features like dual livewells, multiple fishing stations, and room for serious electronics packages.

The trade-offs include higher costs (both purchase and maintenance), more complex trailering requiring heavier tow vehicles, and dock space requirements that some marinas can’t accommodate. These pontoons need 150-200 hp outboards to perform properly, adding $8,000-$15,000 to your total cost.

Budget $50,000-$80,000 new for a well-equipped 24-27 foot fishing pontoon. These are serious investments that make sense if you fish frequently, entertain large groups, or fish big water where size and power matter for safety.

Tube Configuration: Two vs Three Tubes

Standard pontoons ride on two tubes, which works fine for most fishing applications. You get adequate stability, good fuel efficiency, and lower initial cost. The Lowe SF232 uses a traditional two-tube design and handles beautifully on calm to moderate water.

Triple-tube pontoons add a third center tube that dramatically improves stability and weight capacity. This matters when you’re loading up with fishing gear, multiple anglers, and electronics. The Harris Solstice 230 SL with triple tubes can carry 3,000+ pounds versus 2,200 pounds for comparable two-tube models.

Here’s where it gets interesting: triple tubes plane faster, handle chop better, and allow tighter turning at speed. If you fish big lakes where afternoon winds kick up 2-foot waves, that extra tube provides noticeable comfort and control. The downside? You’ll pay $3,000-$8,000 more, and fuel consumption increases by 10-15%.

My recommendation: stick with two tubes for protected waters and calm lakes; consider three tubes if you fish Great Lakes bays, large reservoirs, or anywhere with regular wind and waves.

Comparison Table: Popular Fishing Pontoon Models

Model	Length	Tube Config	Key Fishing Features	Approx. Price (New)	Best For
Lowe SF212 Sport Fish	18 ft	2 tubes	20-gal livewell, 6 rod holders, casting deck	$24,000	Budget-conscious anglers, small lakes
Sun Tracker Fishin’ Barge 22 DLX	22 ft	2 tubes	32-gal aerated livewell, bow fishing deck, trolling motor ready	$38,000	Families, recreational fishing
Bennington 22 SSX	22 ft	3 tubes	Premium livewell, SPS3 triple tubes, extensive storage	$52,000	Serious anglers, rough water
Manitou 25 Legacy SHP	25 ft	3 tubes	Dual livewells, elevated casting platform, commercial-grade construction	$68,000	Professional guides, big water
Avalon Catalina Elite Fish	23 ft	2 tubes	Fishing package with 8 rod holders, 25-gal livewell, trolling motor pre-wired	$42,000	Mid-range, versatile fishing

Power and Performance Considerations

Engine Size Matching

Underpowering a fishing pontoon is the most common mistake buyers make. That beautiful 23-footer might technically accept a 90 hp motor, but you’ll struggle to plane with gear and passengers aboard. The manufacturer’s maximum rating exists for a reason—use at least 75% of it for real-world performance.

A 22-foot pontoon with triple tubes typically needs 115-150 hp for proper performance. Two-tube designs of the same length can manage with 90-115 hp. Don’t let dealers convince you to save money with undersized power—you’ll regret it every time you try to fight wind or current.

Yamaha and Mercury dominate the pontoon outboard market. The Yamaha F115 (115 hp) offers excellent fuel economy and reliability, running $10,000-$12,000. For bigger rigs, the Mercury Verado 150 ($15,000-$17,000) provides smooth power and impressive hole shot with a load.

Trolling Motor Integration

A bow-mounted trolling motor transforms fishing pontoons from good to great. Minn Kota and MotorGuide both offer pontoon-specific mounting systems. The Minn Kota Ultrex 112 (112 pounds thrust) with i-Pilot GPS runs around $2,200 and gives you precise boat control for working structure or maintaining trolling speed.

Check whether your pontoon comes trolling motor ready—meaning it has pre-installed wiring, a mounting plate, and proper battery storage. Adding these aftermarket costs $500-$800 in labor and materials. The Sun Tracker models include 24-volt trolling motor systems as standard on many fishing packages.

Battery placement matters more than most realize. Trolling motor batteries belong up front near the motor to minimize voltage drop through long cable runs. Dedicated battery trays with secure tie-downs and ventilation prevent dangerous situations.

Construction Quality and Materials

Aluminum Gauge Thickness

Not all aluminum is equal. Premium fishing pontoons use .080 or .100 gauge aluminum for pontoon tubes, while budget models might use .065 gauge. That difference matters if you fish rocky shorelines or shallow water where you might scrape bottom.

The Manitou Oasis Angler uses .100 gauge aluminum throughout—it’s heavier and costs more, but you’re buying durability. Bennington’s ESP (Elliptical Sport Package) tubes use .090 gauge with special shaping for better hydrodynamics.

Deck thickness varies too. Look for 3/4-inch marine-grade plywood decking with sealed edges. Cheaper models use 5/8-inch decking that flexes and wears faster. The Crest Classic LX Platinum uses pressure-treated 3/4-inch decking as standard—it costs more but lasts decades.

Furniture and Upholstery

Fishing is hard on boat furniture. You need marine-grade vinyl that resists mildew, UV damage, and the inevitable fish slime. Low-end vinyl shows wear within 2-3 seasons, while premium vinyl (like Bennington’s luxury seating) stays nice for 8-10 years with basic care.

Check the seat frames—aluminum frames outlast plastic significantly. Lift the cushions and inspect mounting hardware. Stainless steel beats zinc-plated screws that corrode and stain your upholstery.

Removable seat bases make sense for serious anglers. The Sun Tracker Party Barge lets you pull out entire seat sections, creating huge open fishing areas when you need them. Boats with permanently fixed furniture limit your options.

Electronics and Fish-Finding Technology

Fishfinder Essentials

Every fishing pontoon needs at minimum a basic fishfinder. Factory electronics packages typically include mid-range units like the Garmin Striker Plus 7sv (around $400) or Lowrance HOOK Reveal 9 (around $600). These show fish, bottom structure, and water temperature—the fundamentals you need.

Serious anglers should consider upgrading to units with side-imaging and down-imaging sonar. The Humminbird HELIX 9 CHIRP MEGA SI+ GPS G4N (around $1,400) reveals incredible detail about structure and baitfish positioning. You’ll locate productive spots faster and understand what’s happening below your boat.

Transducer mounting on pontoons requires specific hardware. Most manufacturers offer through-tube transducer installations that put the sensor between the pontoon tubes for clean readings. Transom-mount transducers work but can get turbulence interference at higher speeds.

Integrated Electronics Packages

High-end fishing pontoons come with complete electronics suites. The Bennington QX Sport includes flush-mounted Garmin units integrated into the helm, creating a clean professional look. Pre-wired systems mean less rat’s nest of cables and cleaner installations.

Consider networked systems that share data between displays. Your fishfinder at the helm can share waypoints with a second display at the bow casting deck. Garmin’s marine network allows multiple screens to show different data from the same transducer.

Power management matters with multiple electronics. Ensure your pontoon has a dedicated marine battery (separate from starting battery) for running fishfinders, GPS units, and trolling motors. Dual battery systems with automatic switching prevent dead battery situations.

New vs Used: Making the Smart Choice

When to Buy New

New fishing pontoons make sense if you want the latest features, full warranties (typically 5-10 years on structure), and the ability to customize exactly what you want. You’re paying premium prices—expect 20-30% above invoice—but you get peace of mind.

Financing is easier with new boats. Most dealers offer 10-15 year loans at 6-9% APR for qualified buyers. That $45,000 pontoon becomes $450/month over 10 years, which fits many budgets better than coming up with $30,000 cash for used.

Factory warranties cover major systems and often include roadside assistance for trailers. Bennington’s Premier Platinum Protection runs 10 years on pontoon logs and deck structure—that’s reassurance worth paying for if you plan to keep the boat long-term.

Used Pontoon Considerations

Smart shoppers can save $10,000-$20,000 buying used 3-5 year old fishing pontoons. Let someone else eat the depreciation while you get a boat that’s barely broken in. The sweet spot is 2019-2021 models with under 200 hours—they’ve depreciated substantially but have lots of life left.

Inspect pontoon tubes carefully for dents, punctures, or leaks. Small dents aren’t deal-breakers, but significant damage raises concerns. Have the boat surveyed by a marine mechanic before buying—$200-$400 spent on inspection can save thousands in hidden problems.

Check service records. Boats with documented maintenance (oil changes, lower unit service, winterization) are worth more than mystery boats with no history. The original owner’s manual and paperwork signals a boat that was cared for properly.

Budget Planning: Total Cost of Ownership

Don’t forget the costs beyond the purchase price. Insurance runs $400-$800 annually for fishing pontoons depending on value and location. Marina fees vary wildly—from $1,200/season for basic slip rental to $4,000+ for premium marinas with amenities.

Registration and taxes catch buyers off-guard. Many states charge sales tax on boat purchases (6-8% of price), plus annual registration ($50-$300). That $40,000 pontoon might cost $42,800 after taxes and first-year registration.

Maintenance isn’t optional. Budget $800-$1,500 annually for routine service: oil changes, lower unit service, winterization/summerization, hull cleaning, and minor repairs. Factor in fuel costs—a 22-foot pontoon with 115 hp burns 5-7 gallons per hour at cruising speed.

Here’s my rule of thumb: your annual operating cost should equal roughly 10% of the boat’s purchase price. A $40,000 fishing pontoon will run you $4,000/year in insurance, maintenance, fuel, and storage. Budget accordingly.

Special Considerations for Different Fishing Styles

Tournament Bass Fishing

Bass tournament anglers need fast hole shot, stability for standing casting, and extensive livewell capacity. The Manitou Legacy SHP series caters specifically to this market with features like aerated livewells with timers, reinforced casting decks rated for 400+ pounds, and layouts designed around quick fish handling.

Weight capacity becomes critical when you’re running with two anglers, full fuel, tournament tackle, and a livewell full of bass. Ensure your chosen model handles this load without compromising performance. Triple-tube designs shine here.

Walleye and Crappie Fishing

Walleye anglers spend hours trolling at precise speeds. Look for pontoons with kicker motor mounts or strong bow trolling motors. The Lowe Ultra series includes kicker motor mounting provisions—add a 9.9 hp kicker for perfect trolling speeds and fuel savings.

Rod storage matters even more for walleye boats. You might run 8-10 rods simultaneously when trolling spinner rigs or cranks. Verify your pontoon has sufficient rod holders mounted strategically around the perimeter. Downrigger mounts (often $150-$300 per side installed) expand your trolling capabilities in deeper water.

Saltwater Fishing

Pontoons work great for inshore saltwater fishing—redfish, speckled trout, snook, and more. You’ll need specific features though: all-aluminum construction (avoid wood decking in saltwater), washdown systems to rinse salt residue, and stainless steel hardware throughout.

Yamaha’s saltwater series outboards or Mercury four-strokes with anti-corrosion treatments are essential. Budget an extra $1,500-$2,500 for saltwater-specific motor protection. Flush your motor religiously after every saltwater outing—neglect this and you’re rebuilding powerheads within a few years.

FAQ: Your Buying Questions Answered

What’s the minimum pontoon size for Great Lakes fishing? I’d recommend 23 feet minimum with triple tubes for Great Lakes fishing. Anything smaller gets uncomfortable quickly in the big water waves these lakes generate. The extra size and third tube provide safety margins when conditions change unexpectedly.

How much does insurance cost for a fishing pontoon? Expect $400-$800 annually for boats valued at $30,000-$50,000. Factors include your location, storage method (indoor vs outdoor), experience level, and coverage limits. Shop multiple insurers—rates vary significantly between companies.

Should I buy a pontoon with aluminum or vinyl flooring? Aluminum flooring is virtually indestructible but gets hot in summer sun and cold in spring. Vinyl flooring over plywood stays cooler, provides cushioning, and looks nicer but can get damaged by hooks and fish. Most serious fishing pontoons use vinyl for comfort.

Can you add a fishing package to a regular pontoon? Yes, but it’s expensive and time-consuming. Installing a livewell system aftermarket runs $1,500-$3,000 including plumbing and electrical. Adding rod holders, mounting plates, and storage costs another $800-$1,500 in parts and labor. Buy the fishing package from the factory and save money.

What’s better for fishing: tiller or console steering? Console steering wins for fishing pontoons over 20 feet. You get better visibility, more comfortable operation, and room for electronics. Tiller steering only makes sense on compact pontoons under 18 feet where simplicity and cost matter more than comfort.

How long do fishing pontoons last? With proper maintenance, quality fishing pontoons last 20-30+ years. The aluminum tubes are nearly indestructible if you avoid major collisions. Furniture and flooring wear out every 10-15 years but can be replaced. Bennington has boats from the 1990s still on the water looking good.

Do fishing pontoons hold their value? Better than you’d think. Fishing boats depreciate roughly 10-15% the first year, then 5-7% annually for years 2-10. A well-maintained $40,000 fishing pontoon might be worth $32,000 after three years—not terrible compared to cars that lose 30-40% in the same period.

Making Your Final Decision

Start by honestly assessing how you’ll actually use the boat. Will you fish alone or with family? What species are you targeting? How often will you be on the water? A boat that sits unused because it’s too big or too expensive to operate isn’t a good investment regardless of features.

Visit dealers during off-season (late fall or winter) for better negotiating leverage. Dealers are motivated to move inventory before spring rush begins. Don’t be afraid to ask for upgrades or accessories thrown in—trailer upgrades, covers, extended warranties, and electronics packages are all negotiable.

Test drive before buying—never purchase a pontoon without running it on water. Feel how it handles, check sight lines from the helm, and walk around visualizing your fishing scenarios. Sit in every seat. Open every compartment. Make sure this boat truly fits your needs.

Remember that the “perfect” fishing pontoon doesn’t exist—you’re always balancing compromises between features, size, cost, and functionality. The goal is finding the model that best matches your fishing style, budget, and the waters you’ll be navigating most often.

What’s your biggest concern about choosing a fishing pontoon? Share in the comments and let’s help each other make smarter buying decisions!

---

References

• National Marine Manufacturers Association: Pontoon market data and specifications
• Lowe Boats: https://www.loweboats.com/pontoons
• Bennington Marine: https://www.benningtonmarine.com
• Sun Tracker Boats: https://www.suntracker.com
• Discover Boating: Cost of ownership calculators and buyer guides
• BoatUS: Insurance and ownership resources